二、隨著經濟全球化及自由貿易的推動,在地國的管制能力及其勞動關係皆受到衝擊。試從福利國家的角度,論述在全球化競爭下對勞動市場的衝擊為何?在地工會在集體勞動關係架構下,能夠採行何種策略?(50分)

4.From the viewpoints of the government and the leftwing supporters, are the protests considered "deviant behavior"? Please compare the ways in which "deviance" is defined by these two (groups of) actors, and discuss how they may shape the construction of social reality in this incident.